Explainer graphic: key climate numbers for 2025 and 2026, four common skeptic claims with what the records show, and four steps for checking a climate chart
Five popular climate doubts, each checked against a measurement anyone can look up.

Someone in the family group chat posts a chart. It shows temperatures going down, and the caption says the whole warming story is overblown. You have a hunch it is wrong, but you cannot say why. Annoying, isn't it?

The short answer: Doubt is healthy when it asks a question that can be tested. The best-known skeptic claims have been tested, many times, and the measurements keep pointing the same way. The planet is warming, and human emissions are the main cause. Here is how five common claims hold up.

Where the numbers stand

Start with the scoreboard. The World Meteorological Organization says 2025 was the second or third hottest year on record, about 1.43 °C above the 1850-1900 average. It also says 2015 to 2025 are the hottest 11 years on record.

Carbon dioxide keeps climbing too. NOAA's Mauna Loa record shows a monthly average of 426.07 parts per million for September 2026, up from 424.37 a year earlier. For scale, NOAA notes that over the past million years, CO2 never climbed higher than 300 ppm.

Five claims, five checks

Common skeptic claims and what the records show
The claimWhat the evidence says
"Warming stopped in 1998"1998 was an unusually hot year. Start a chart there and the trend looks flatter. Records fell again in 2014, 2015 and 2016.
"It's the Sun"Solar energy shows no net rise since the 1950s. Temperature rose anyway.
"Antarctic ice is growing"Floating sea ice swings from year to year. The ice sheets on land are losing mass.
"Climate always changed"True, and those changes had causes. Today's CO2 rise is far faster than the natural ones.
"Scientists don't agree"About 97% of climate scientists say human-caused change is happening.

The 1998 claim is a lesson in start dates. A strong El Niño made that year a record, so NOAA explains that a trend beginning there is more likely to look cool. Surface warming did slow from 1998 to 2012. The oceans kept gaining heat, seas kept rising, and new temperature records followed.

The Sun claim has a neat test. If a brighter Sun were to blame, the whole atmosphere would warm, top to bottom. Instead, NASA points out, the surface is warming while the stratosphere cools. That pattern fits heat-trapping gases near the ground, not a hotter star.

The ice mix-up

Ice claims usually blend two different things. Sea ice is a thin seasonal layer on the ocean, generally about a metre thick or less. Land ice is the glaciers and ice sheets sitting on the continent. The two do not have to move together.

Antarctic sea ice did hit a record winter high in September 2014. Then, in February 2023, it fell to a record summer low, as NOAA's sea ice explainer describes. Meanwhile, NASA's satellite data for 1993 to 2019 puts land ice losses at about 148 billion tons a year in Antarctica and 279 billion in Greenland.

How we know the CO2 is ours

This is the cleverest bit of detective work. Carbon comes in different weights, and plants prefer the light kind. Fossil fuels are very old plant matter, so burning them tilts the air towards light carbon. That tilt is what the measurements show.

Volcanoes fail the test, because their carbon is rich in the heavier kind. Fossil carbon also has no measurable carbon-14, and the air's carbon-14 is falling faster than natural mixing explains. NOAA's conclusion is that only fossil fuels fit every clue.

Check a climate chart in four steps

  1. Read the labels. Which place, which measurement, which years? One city's winter cannot answer a question about the whole globe.
  2. Move the start date. If the conclusion vanishes when the chart begins five years earlier, the start year was doing the work.
  3. Find the original data. NASA, NOAA and the WMO publish theirs. A cropped screenshot with no source is not evidence.
  4. Look for a second measure. Air temperature, ocean heat, sea level and ice are tracked separately. A real trend shows up in more than one.

The same habit works well beyond climate. It is close to the routine for fact-checking an answer from a chatbot: find the original, then see if a second source agrees.

Frequently asked questions

Is it wrong to be skeptical about climate change?

No. Science runs on doubt. The trouble starts when a doubt has already been answered and keeps circulating anyway. Arguing about what to do, who pays and how fast is a separate debate. You can question a policy without disputing the thermometer.

Do scientists really agree on the cause?

Broadly, yes. NASA's consensus page cites a 2014 statement from the American Association for the Advancement of Science that about 97% of climate scientists have concluded human-caused climate change is happening. It also lists many other science bodies saying much the same.

So next time that chart lands in the chat, skip the shouting match. Ask where the data came from and what year it starts. Those two questions settle a lot of these arguments, and they are polite enough for a family group.