Explainer graphic: how to decide between repairing and replacing a gadget, with the global e-waste numbers, a cost-per-year comparison and five questions to ask before paying
Name the fault, price the fix, check the software, then compare cost per year.

The screen has a crack, the battery dies by lunch, and a shiny replacement is one tap away. Before you tap, it is worth five minutes of arithmetic. The cheapest gadget is very often the one already in your hand.

The short answer: repair when one part has failed, the fix costs under half the price of a comparable new device, and the software still gets security updates. Replace when updates have ended, parts no longer exist, or faults keep arriving in a queue. Either way, decide on cost per year of use, not on the sticker.

Why one more year matters

The Global E-waste Monitor 2024 counted 62 million tonnes of e-waste in 2022, growing by 2.6 million tonnes a year. Only 22.3 per cent was documented as properly collected and recycled. About US$62 billion of recoverable materials went unaccounted for.

Recycling helps, but keeping a device in service helps sooner. A 2019 study for the European Environmental Bureau put the average smartphone life at three years. It estimated that one extra year across the EU would save more than 2 million tonnes of emissions. For phones, it found, the emissions that matter most come from making them.

Name the fault first

"It's old" is not a diagnosis. Write down what is actually wrong, because each problem has a different next move.

Four situations and what to check next
What is wrongWhat to checkUsual verdict
One part failed (battery, screen, port)Repair quote, part availability, warranty on the repairRepair
It feels slowStorage space, battery health, a memory or drive upgradeTune or upgrade
Software support has endedThe maker's update policy and any paid or free extensionRetire it from banking and email, or replace
You just want the new oneYour own honestySell or gift the old one while it still has value

Batteries deserve a special mention, because a tired battery makes a perfectly good phone feel finished. Apple says iPhone 14 and earlier models are designed to keep 80 per cent of capacity at 500 full charge cycles under ideal conditions, and iPhone 15 models at 1,000. Below that, a battery swap is a repair, not a funeral.

Do the cost-per-year sum

The old rule of thumb comes from Consumer Reports, which in 2014 advised against spending more than 50 per cent of a new product's cost on repairing an old one. The same survey of 29,281 subscribers found customers of independent repair shops more satisfied than those who used factory service.

Treat 50 per cent as a starting line. A March 2026 guide in the trade publication ServiceMag calls it a blunt instrument: it ignores age, the kind of failure and what comes next. A young machine is nearly always worth fixing. A fault that signals wider wear may not be, even when the bill is small.

So add time to the sum. A made-up example: a repair costing 60 that buys two more years costs 30 a year. A replacement costing 240 that lasts four years costs 60 a year. The repair wins on paper, unless the device is about to lose its updates.

Five questions before you pay

  1. What exactly failed? Get a diagnosis and a written quote, not a shrug.
  2. Is it under half the price of a comparable new one? Compare like with like, not with the flagship.
  3. How long will updates last? Check how long your phone gets security updates. A Windows 10 PC still works, and Microsoft's extended updates run to 12 October 2027.
  4. Could an upgrade do it? The US EPA suggests upgrading a computer's hardware or software before buying new.
  5. Is the repair guaranteed? Ask how long, and get it on the receipt.

Buy the next one to be fixable

The law is starting to help. Phones and tablets sold in the EU since 20 June 2025 carry a repairability score from A to E. Batteries must survive 800 cycles at 80 per cent, spare parts must stay available for seven years, and updates must run for five.

The EU's Right to Repair Directive was due in national law by 31 July 2026. Choose repair over replacement under warranty and the legal guarantee grows by at least a year. Coverage is uneven: the Commission opened proceedings against 18 member states in September.

In India, a government committee recommended in May 2025 a five-point repairability index for phones and tablets, declared by makers and shown at the point of sale. Wherever you live, ask about parts and update years before you buy, and keep the answer with the receipt.

Frequently asked questions

Is it safe to keep using a device that no longer gets updates?

It will still switch on, but the risk grows. Microsoft says an unsupported Windows 10 PC keeps working while becoming more exposed to viruses and malware. Give such a device an offline job, such as a music player or a kitchen recipe screen, and keep banking and email off it.

What if repair really is not worth it?

Then recycle it properly. The EPA cites an estimate that a million recycled phones yield 35,000 pounds of copper, 772 pounds of silver and 75 pounds of gold. Our guide on how to wipe an old phone or laptop and where it should go covers the handover.

So, before the upgrade itch wins: name the fault, get one quote, check the update date, and divide each price by the years it buys. If the repair wins, book it this week. If it loses, wipe the device and send it somewhere that can prove what happens next.